Comparisons
Notion vs Google Docs vs Discord for D&D
Notion, Google Docs or Discord for your D&D campaign? An honest look at each for notes, quests, NPCs and GM secrets, and when a campaign manager fits better.
By Mythical AtlasLast updated
Most groups don't choose their campaign tools on purpose. The GM starts a Google Doc for notes, someone sets up a Discord server for scheduling, and a few months later a player suggests moving everything into Notion. Each of these can work for a D&D campaign, and each struggles in different places.
This comparison looks at Notion, Google Docs and Discord for running a tabletop RPG campaign, and at where a dedicated TTRPG campaign manager like Mythical Atlas fits. We build Mythical Atlas, so we've tried to be fair about its limits too. None of these tools is the right answer for every group, and many groups end up using two of them together.
What a campaign needs from its tools
Before comparing tools, it helps to list the jobs they have to do:
- Talk: scheduling, banter, and voice for online games.
- Reference: house rules, lore and character creation guidelines.
- Tracking: which quests are open, what the party owns, and who they've met.
- Recaps: a session-by-session history of what happened.
- Secrets: a private space for the GM's prep and anything not yet revealed.
- Access: every player can reach it easily, ideally without paying.
Google Docs
Google Docs is where many campaigns start, because almost everyone already has a Google account and knows how to use it.
Where it works well
-
Free with a Google account, and it works on any device.
-
Real-time co-editing and comments make it good for collaborative recaps.
-
Sharing is set per document (view, comment or edit), so the GM can keep prep in a separate doc nobody else can open.
-
Document tabs let one doc hold several sections, such as one tab per session. Where it struggles
-
Campaign docs grow long quickly, and long documents get hard to navigate even with tabs and headings.
-
Tracking is up to you. Quest lists, NPC tables and inventories are text you structure and keep current yourself, and they don't filter or sort like a database.
-
Information tends to spread across many docs and folders, so players need to know where to look. Best for: short campaigns, small groups, or a shared space for recaps.
Notion
Notion is a flexible workspace of pages and databases, and it's popular with GMs who like to build their own systems.
Where it works well
-
Databases can track quests, NPCs and locations with properties such as status or tags, and display them as tables, boards or galleries.
-
Pages link to each other, so you can build a wiki-style campaign setting.
-
Community-made TTRPG templates can give you a starting point.
-
A free plan is available. Where it struggles
-
You design and maintain the system yourself. Some GMs love that; for others it's one more prep job.
-
Players need to learn how your setup works before they can find things in it.
-
Sharing some pages with players while keeping others private takes careful permission setup. Check Notion's current plans for how guest access works on the free tier. Best for: GMs who enjoy building their own tools and want full control over structure.
Discord
Discord is where a lot of groups already hang out, especially those who play online.
Where it works well
-
Text and voice channels in one place make it the natural home for scheduling, banter and online sessions.
-
Threads, forum channels and pinned messages help keep topics together.
-
Built-in polls make quick decisions, like picking a session date, easy.
-
It's free to use, with the paid Nitro subscription being optional.
-
Dice bots and other integrations are widely available. Where it struggles
-
Conversations scroll away. The house rule from three months ago is buried under thousands of messages.
-
It's a chat app, not a reference library. Checking a quest's status or looking up an NPC means searching old messages or keeping pinned posts updated by hand. Best for: communication, scheduling and voice. Most groups keep using it no matter where their notes live.
A dedicated campaign manager: Mythical Atlas
A TTRPG campaign manager comes with the pages a campaign needs already built, so the GM fills them in instead of designing a system. Here's an honest look at both sides of Mythical Atlas.
Where it works well
-
Every campaign gets ready-made pages: a quest board with statuses, types, locations and priorities; a Glossary for NPCs, monsters, items and locations, including full creature stat blocks; Rules and Info pages with a table of contents; Updates for recaps; Notes; Maps; Polls; a Shop with merchants and custom currencies; a Player Keep; a Codex of rollable custom tables; and a Dice Roller.
-
GM secrets are built in: private Glossary entries, Codex tables that stay private until shared, and quest XP you can hide from players.
-
Players join with an invite code, the GM approves them, and players never pay.
-
It's system-agnostic, so it works for D&D 5e, Pathfinder, OSR and homebrew games. Where it falls short
-
There's no text chat or voice, so most groups keep Discord or something similar for talking.
-
Map images are hosted elsewhere (Imgur or Google Drive, for example) and added by link rather than uploaded directly.
-
It's more structured than Notion. Notes, Info pages and Codex tables are flexible, but you can't redesign the app's layout.
-
Running a real campaign requires a Game Master subscription. Anyone can try the GM tools first in Sandbox Mode, which is free and capped at 5 entries per category. Best for: GMs running long campaigns who want quests, NPCs, rules and recaps organized without building the system themselves, and players who want one place to look things up.
Side-by-side comparison
| Google Docs | Notion | Discord | Mythical Atlas | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built for | Documents | Pages and databases | Chat and voice | TTRPG campaigns |
| Cost for players | Free with a Google account | Free plan available | Free (Nitro optional) | Free |
| Cost for the GM | Free with a Google account | Free plan available | Free (Nitro optional) | Subscription; free Sandbox Mode to try |
| Quest tracking | Lists you maintain | Build your own database | Posts or threads you maintain | Quest board with statuses |
| NPC and monster lookup | Search the doc | Build your own database | Search old messages | Glossary with stat blocks |
| GM secrets | Separate, unshared docs | Pages you don't share | Private channels | Private entries and hidden XP |
| Voice for online sessions | No | No | Yes | No |
| Setup | Quick | You design the structure | Quick | Pages are prebuilt |
Which should you choose?
- Google Docs if your campaign is short, your group is small, and you mainly need a shared place for notes and recaps.
- Notion if you enjoy designing your own system and want complete control over how everything is structured.
- Discord for talking, scheduling and voice. It's a great communication hub, just not a great archive.
- A dedicated campaign manager like Mythical Atlas if you're running a long campaign and want quests, NPCs, rules and recaps organized from day one, with players able to look things up on their own. Plenty of groups land on a combination: Discord for conversation, plus one home for everything the party needs to remember. If you're setting up that home now, our guide to organizing a D&D campaign walks through what to track and a simple routine for each session.
